Christian Life 

The Miracle of Dunkirk: 70 years on

In what is still called 'the Miracle of Dunkirk' the story is told of how over 300,000 British troops were snatched from the beaches of France in an operation that was so fraught with dangers that success can only be attributed to a miraculous combination of circumstances.
 
 
by David E. Gardner

Dunkirk1MAY 1940 was a time of grave crisis for the British Empire and for the whole civilised world.

On 10 May Hitler had launched his blitzkrieg against the Low Countries and France. By the end of the second week in May the French defences had been broken. German panzer forces, led by Rommel and his 7th Panzer Division, burst through, and with lightning speed began a rapid advance across France and Belgium. Very soon Rommel's armoured pincer movement was threatening the British army with encirclement, and our forces were being obliged to withdraw.

Back at home Mr Churchill feared that it would be his hard lot to announce the greatest military disaster in our long history, whilst on 27 May the German High Command went so far as to boast that 'The British army is encircled and our troops are proceeding to its annihilation.'

With the entire front collapsing rapidly, the decision was reached at home to evacuate our forces from the Continent. But the only port from which to evacuate the British Expeditionary Force was Dunkirk, and that was already being seriously threatened by the Germans. Taking stock of the predicament, Churchill said in The Second World War. 'I thought—and some good judges agreed with me—that perhaps 20,000 or 30,000 men might be re-embarked. The whole root and core and brain of the British army... seemed about to perish upon the field, or to be led into ignominious and starving captivity.' All therefore seemed about to be lost.

 

Britain had a godly Sovereign

 


But Britain had a godly Sovereign. Seeing this situation developing, His Majesty King George VI requested that Sunday, 26 May should be observed as a National Day of Prayer. In a stirring broadcast, he called the people of Britain and of the Empire to commit their cause to God. Together with members of the Cabinet, the King attended Westminster Abbey, whilst millions of his subjects in all parts of the Commonwealth and Empire flocked to the churches to join in prayer. Britain was given inspiring leadership in those days, and her people responded immediately when this kind of initiative was taken. The whole nation was at prayer on that Sunday. The scene outside Westminster Abbey was remarkable—photographs show long queues of people who could not even get in, the Abbey was so crowded! So much so, that the following morning the Daily Sketch exclaimed, 'Nothing like it has ever happened before.'
In its hour of deep distress a heart-cry from both monarch and people alike was going up to God in prayer. And that cry did not go unanswered. For very soon, at least three miracles were seen to happen.

 

The first miracle

 


The first was that for some reason—which has never yet been fully explained—Hitler overruled his generals and halted the advance of his armoured columns at the very point when they could have proceeded to the British army's annihilation. They were now only ten miles away! Later, Mr Churchill asserted in his memoirs that this was because Hitler undoubtedly believed 'that his air superiority would be sufficient to prevent a large-scale evacuation by sea.' That is very significant in terms of the second miracle.
 

The second miracle

 


A storm of unprecedented fury broke over Flanders on Tuesday, 28 May, (1940) grounding the German Luftwaffe squadrons and enabling the British army formations, now eight to twelve miles from Dunkirk, to move up on foot to the coast in the darkness of the storm and the violence of the rain, with scarcely any interruption from aircraft, which were unable to operate in such turbulent conditions. The Fuehrer had obviously not taken the weather into his reckoning, nor the One who controls the weather! And the third miracle?
 

The third miracle

 


Despite the storm in Flanders, a great calm—such as has rarely been experienced—settled over the English Channel during the days which followed, and its waters became as still as a mill pond.
It was this quite extraordinary calm which enabled a vast armada of little ships, big ships, warships, privately owned motor-cruisers from British rivers and estuaries – in fact, almost anything that would float – to ply back and forth in a desperate bid to rescue as many of our men as possible.

 

The Little Ships

 


LIttle ShipsThere were so many ships involved in the evacuation that this is the way in which Douglas Bader, the legless Spitfire fighter ace, who sped over with his squadrons from the fighter base at Martlesham, near Ipswich, to help cover the operation, described the scene in Fight for the Sky: "The sea from Dunkirk to Dover during these days of the evacuation looked like any coastal road in England on a bank holiday. It was solid with shipping. One felt one could walk across without getting one's feet wet, or that's what it looked like from the air. There were naval escort vessels, sailing dinghies, rowing boats, paddle-steamers, indeed every floating device known in this country. They were all taking British soldiers from Dunkirk back home. You could identify Dunkirk from the Thames estuary by the huge pall of black smoke rising straight up into a windless sky from the oil tanks which were ablaze just inside the harbour."

Yet still, to a very large extent, the German air squadrons were unable to intervene. Certainly not in force, nor in the way Hitler had anticipated, for so many of these squadrons still remained grounded. So much so that General Haider, Chief of the German General Staff, three days after the High Command had so proudly boasted that the British Army was about to be annihilated, was obliged to record in his diary on 30 May that 'Bad weather has grounded the Luftwaffe, and now we must stand by and watch countless thousands of the enemy getting away to England right under our noses.'

 

A strange immunity

 


DunkirkEven though some squadrons did get through, it seems that yet another miracle happened.

Many of the troops on the beaches were favoured with a strange immunity. When about 400 men were being machine-gunned and bombed, systematically, by about sixty enemy aircraft, one man who flung himself down with the rest reported that, after the strafing was over, he was amazed to find that there was not a single casualty.
 
Another man, a chaplain, was likewise machine-gunned and bombed as he lay on the beach. After what seemed an eternity, he realized he had not been hit, and rose to his feet to find that the sand all around where he had been lying was pitted with bullet holes, and that his figure was outlined on the ground.

 

Amazing events

 


Truly, amazing things were happening. There were signs on every hand that an intervening Power was at work. Officers and men alike had seen the hand of God, powerful to save, delivering them from the hands of a mighty foe who, humanly speaking, had them at its mercy.
And they were not slow to say so. Even Fleet Street has placed it on record that two miracles had made possible what had seemed impossible.

 

A Day of National Thanksgiving

 


So grateful was the nation for this mighty deliverance that Sunday, 9 June 1940 was appointed as a Day of National Thanksgiving. On the eve of that day, C. B. Mortlock stated in an article in The Daily Telegraph that 'the prayers of the nation were answered', and that 'the God of hosts himself had supported the valiant men of the British Expeditionary Force.'

Two great wonders stand forth', he said. On them have turned the fortune of our troops.
'I have talked to officers and men who have got safely back to England, and all of them tell of these two phenomena. The first was the great storm which broke over Flanders on Tuesday, 28 May. The second was the great calm which settled on the English Channel during the days following.
'Officers of high rank do not hesitate to put down the deliverance of the British Expeditionary Force to the fact of the nation being at prayer on Sunday, 26 May, two days before that great storm in Flanders and the calm that came over the Channel.'

The word 'miracle' was soon being heard on all sides, and a consciousness of a miraculous deliverance pervaded the camps in which the troops were being housed back in England.
Mr Churchill, when he chose 4 June as the occasion for making a statement to the House of Commons, spoke with a voice charged with emotion when he reported that, rather than 20,000 or 30,000 men being re-embarked, '335,000 men had been carried out of the jaws of death and shame to their native land. He referred to what had happened as 'a miracle of deliverance'.

 

Psalm124 sung in the churches

 


When the services of national thanksgiving were held in all churches on the following Sunday, 9 June, it was with great feeling that many a choir and congregation sang the words of Psalm 124, for they were seen to apply to that situation through which the nation had just passed:

'If the Lord himself had not been on our side, now may Israel say: if the Lord himself had not been on our side, when men rose up against us; They would have swallowed us up quick: when they were so wrathfully displeased at us. Yea, the waters had drowned us: and the stream had gone over our soul. The deep waters of the proud would have gone over our soul. But praised be the Lord: Who has not given us over for a prey unto their teeth. Our soul is escaped even as a bird out of the snare of the fowler: the snare is broken, and we are delivered. Our help standeth in the name of the Lord: who hath made heaven and earth'

No other passage of Scripture could have more aptly described the nation's experience on that day. The words seem to have been especially written for the occasion.


 
Trumpet SoundsFootnote: The above article is extracted from a trilogy entitled 'The Trumpet Sounds for Britain' written by Rev. David E Gardner who went to be with the Lord in 2002 just before the trilogy was republished. Whilst serving in the Royal Navy during WW2, an emergency in a submarine caused him to recognise the miraculous deliverance of God.
This personal deliverance later helped him to understand what God had done for the people of Britain as a whole, many times in their history.
The trilogy which is available from the publishers chronicles the development and growth of Christianity in Britain from the earliest times. However his 'Trumpet' writings are prophetic in nature and in many ways anticipate and speak into our present condition.
 

David E. Gardner, 28/05/2010

Feedback:
(page   1   2   3)
Penny Lee 30/05/2010 18:06
Hi Rob,

Was your father or grandfather a minister by any chance? If so, did he minister in a Baptist Church in Glasgow around 1950?

Thanks,
Andrea
W Benn (Guest) 30/05/2010 22:26
I declare that history is my favourite subject and whilst there is much factual accuracy within the piece I am flabbergasted by some of the interpretation.It would be easy for me to take the view that history has been trashed here and am loath to take that line.I will revisit this time in history and have another look at it!


Donald Boyd 06/06/2010 00:02
If you read the book Mr Benn, you will find it quotes contemporary newspaper sources as well as Churchill's speeches.


W Benn (Guest) 24/06/2010 22:04
So Hitler, not for the first time, miscalculated; he was an uneducated and unstable man unfit for high office but he gained it on the back of so called charismatic speeches, economic conditions, past political factors, terror, and a degree of poisonous propanganda.

What remains? The weather was very favourable to our forces.We know much about the weather; it fluctuates so much and was said to be a very large factor in our victory at the Battle of Waterloo; it also gave no favours to the Spanish Armada at a key time for us. What are we to deduce from all that? Have we got God on our side? Are you really going to claim that God manipulated the weather? It seems to me that you are. He did not manipulate anything at the Battle of the Somme in WW1 unless he wishes to put his hand up for the utter carnage.

Part of the argument is the power of prayer but there is a problem with that; there is no evidence, under scientific conditions, that would convince a rational person of the power of prayer except for those with an over riding sense of wishful thinking.That is not meant to be taken as a personal insult and I hope readers will accept that is my honest declaration.

With regard to those uninjured in a particular attack I offer the thought that many of our troops did die during their attempt to delay the German Army from reaching the coast.

If high ranking people were convinced of Godly deliverance that is up to them. Whatever our station in life we should think for ourselves having duly sought the best evidence and advice; high ranking people are not always the most reliable people to supply or give it. Many people seek meaning in the bible and even more do not. It is all a matter of choice and strength of conviction.


Alec (Guest) 24/06/2010 23:50
The whole business of "God on our side" always strikes me as being a bit of a case of confirmation bias

At school, in English lessons, we studied the "July Plot" - when several high ranking German officers tried to assasinate Hitler. They failed. The bomb went off, Hitler survived, the war went on for another year, millions died and the Soviets over-ran half of Europe.

The question is, where was God in that room? Why did the plot fail? Killing Hitler then would have saved millions of lives and probably spared Europe from the shadow of the Cold War.

After all, Hitler did eventually die, so his failure was obviously part of Gods plan.

My own view is that God isnt as interventionist as a lot of people would like to think he is.

"Gott mit Uns" (God with us) was the slogan on the buckles of the Wehrmacht (as opposed to "Mein Ehre heist Treue" of the SS)

Maybe he wasnt....

Think about it

BTW, Hitler understood his survival to be a "divine moment in history"

Also, one of the conspirators, von Stauffenberg, was reluctant to take part in an assasination because of his religious convictions (Catholic) . However, he moved on to believing in the "lesser of 2 evils"

Seldom are things as black and white as some people would paint them
a h 08/12/2010 23:00
Still debating Mr Benn? I'd just love to know what your motive is.
Heather Farquharson (Guest) 28/05/2011 06:21
What a miracle, this is just confirmation that we have a great and glorious God that never lets us down. God will always respond to prayer and will answer our needs.
It is absolutely amazing to hear that the nation came together for prayer, that Westminster Abbey couldn't even contain the amount of people that were coming to pray in unity. It is also great to see that Winston Churchill was also a man after God's heart that he saw the value of prayer. I pray that today our leaders will also take their direction from God in obedience and faith.
C.E.C. (Guest) 08/08/2011 01:24
Thank you for posting this article. I look forward to reading more.

One writer, W. Benn, confidently stated the power of prayer has not been validated "under scientific conditions." What is he talking about? Where's his empirical evidence? Answers to prayer occur every day; I was healed of a physical condition in almost a moment's time, and I've witnessed the physical healing of a relative. I know of other confirmed healings through the power of prayer, one from a neighbor with free-floating cartilege in his knee who could barely walk who went on to work six days a week as a successful landscaper.

Pundits and anti-Christian naysayers can try to repudiate/denigrate the power of God working with nature -- as at Flanders and the English channel -- but it's not a new occurrence. The cliffs surrounding the Red Sea are filled with ancient etchings that describe the passing of the Jews through the water that "rose up in a heap" (read "The Signature of God" by Canadian historian/writer Grant Jeffreys).

Why don't miracles occur when we think they should? This is planet earth...NOT heaven. The rain falls on the just and the unjust alike, and God is kind to the wicked (as spoken by Jesus in Matthew and Luke). And there are spiritual forces that labor intensively against goodness. (There's a reason for the popular ghost-related reality TV shows: many people know empirically that the spirit world exists.)

Men and women of prayer who offer up supplications with humble, sincere hearts all bare witness to sometimes receiving favor via silent, inner promptings that convey words of wisdom, knowledge, and even prophecy that are proven true. And, yes, sometimes physical healings do occur. (Read "The Happiest People on Earth" by Demos Shakarian re. documented healings of family members, including himself. One occurred in a hospital under the watchful eyes of medical staff)

Writer Betty Malz, an established intercessor (someone who regularly prays comfort and blessings for others), prayed secretly every day that a friend with crossed eyes would be healed. Weeks later, her friend's eyes uncrossed while working in her yard with her husband.

I find it very questionable when people who don't pray almost gleefully try to rob others of their valid experiences. What is their real objective? You'd think they would be pleased when others are blessed.
Editor 08/08/2011 08:56
Thank you C.E.C. Praise God for your healing. If you have a written-up testimony I would be very pleased to see a copy.

There are (not-infrequent) scoffings on the subject of healing and the often-exaggerated claims of 'healers' provide easy targets.

However the effect is to rob the church of the gifts of God (often at the hands of theologians who develop their theology within the constraints of their own experience).

Watch this space for a soon-coming article on 'Cessationism'.
Len Lannom (Guest) 03/11/2011 01:48
I have read that the 400 men traped on the beach at Dunkirk shouted at the top of their lungs Psalms 91. I believe thiswas reported by C.B. Mortlock.
(page   1   2   3)

NOTICE: - The 'Response' facility on some articles may be restricted to CT site members. In these circumstances comments/questions from non-site members should be sent to the Editor by e-mail: editor<atsign>christianstogether.net

Christians Together in the Highlands and Islands > Christian Life > The Miracle of Dunkirk: 70 years on