The End of Life Assistance (Scotland) Bill Committee rejected the End of Live Assistance (Scotland) Bill by 5 votes to 1 vote.
One of the main problems with how the Bill was worded is that the breadth of people the Bill would have impacted would be so wide as to include people with heart disease and Type 1 diabetes, as well as those suffering from terminal illnesses.
The inadequacy of the safeguards against undue influence on people to end their lives has been identified in the report, as has the negative impact such a Bill would have on the disabled.
It also firmly comes down on the side of protecting the interests of society rather than allowing the notion of personal autonomy to be stretched to permit assisted suicide and euthanasia.
The Bill’s lack of objectivity and clarity have also been criticised - indeed the committee recognised that it even fails to use the terms voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide.
The lack of a conscience clause, and the question of the level of competence of those involved in any such process, shows that regulation of the medical profession would have to be examined if such an option were ever available.
CARE for Scotland Manager Bill Baird said: “This is a welcome outcome and a fair assessment of the End of Life Bill. Evidence has emerged from countries like the Netherlands or in the US state Oregon which clearly shows the weakness of changing end of life laws particularly in relation to the disproportionate danger such changes pose to vulnerable people. We currently have the balance right, so we are happy with the outcome of the report.”
All in all, this is a comprehensive rejection of a Bill which would have posed an enormous danger to many people and would have seriously undermined the dignity of sick and dying people in society.
CARE is pleased that the Committee has provided a thorough analysis of the bill and highlighted its many dangers. Aside from the fact that the bill proposes legalizing assisted suicide, one of the main problems with it is the range of conditions it would cover beyond terminal illness.
Chief Executive of CARE, Nola Leach said: “It is paramount that in all parts of the United Kingdom the laws which protect human life particularly at the later stage of life are upheld. We should be proud of the fact that the UK offers the best palliative care in the world, so rather than changing the law we need to continue to support palliative care. Death is not a choice like any other.”
The bill has yet to be presented to the Scottish Parliament and is due to be voted on by the whole parliament in plenary on either the 24th or 25th of November. The proposed legislation has been championed by veteran parliamentarian Margo Macdonald MSP. Parkinson’s disease sufferer Ms MacDonald, who rejected claims that her bill could result in up to 1,000 deaths a year, claimed most MSPs on the committee had a “known hostility” to the basic principle of her proposals.
See article Assisted suicide: the thin end of the wedge where a letter from Brian Ross and an article from Dr. Stephen Hutchison (Highland Hospice) address the subject of euthanasia.
(Author: CARE/Christians Together)
Midwives lose right to desist from abortions
Archbishop Mario Conti has spoken out in response to a court ruling whereby two senior midwives from Glasgow have lost their battle not to assist in abortions. (Author: Catholic Herald)
Doctors against abortions in surgeries
A recent poll of GPs show that a third of GPs are unwilling to implement Government proposals which would see women having abortions in local surgeries. (Author: Christians Together)
Highland health workers pray for their patients
Highland health workers including GPs, consultants and nurses show concern for the spiritual needs of those in their care by praying for them - and sometimes with them. (Author: Christians Together)
Christian nurse suspended for offering to pray
A Christian community nurse has been suspended after offering to pray with one of her patients. The patient declined and informed the hospital trust. (Author: Christian Legal Centre/Christians Together)
From my mother's womb you have been my God
The story of one family's experience of God's provision for their premature baby and the intimacy of His care for those whom he has created. (Author: Christians Together)
Scotland's worsening sexual health
New statistics show that strategies which are devoid of a moral dimension are continuing to halt the rapid rise in sexually transmitted infections in Scotland (Author: Christians Together)
We trust our medics, don't we?
The recent case of a Glasgow GP who has been sentenced to a six-month suspension by the GMC raises the question of trust in the medical profession. (Author: Watchman)
Abortions in Scotland
A graph showing the number of abortions taking place in Scotland each year from 1968 - 2007 (Author: Christians Together)
Care Confidential operate a helpline and a network of Crisis Pregnancy Centres throughout the UK offering advice and support to those who are considering or who have had an abortion. (Author: Christians Together)
This section of the Christians Together web site covers health related issues from a Christian perspective. (Author: )
Abortion Wake-up Call from Strasbourg
CARE have expressed great concern at the passing of the Resolution ‘Legal Abortion in Europe’ which claims that women have a 'right' to obtain an abortion. (Author: CARE)
Abortion raises risk of breast cancer
A new study shows that countries (like the UK) with a higher rate of abortion could expect to see a substantial increase in the incidence of breast cancer. (Author: )
Widespread support for anti-abortion pupil
A young mum who is also a school pupil is receiving widespread support for her stand against abortion and the difficulties she has faced from her school. (Author: )